Is dependency a infirmity? This question has been debated upon for several old age yet a final end was never made. In the passage Ain?t Misbehavin?, Stanley Peele argues that habituation is not a disease since it has never been go upd to be it. He tries to go for his point by stating general differences between addictions and diseases and defending close to other authors? statements. He says that if addiction is accepted as a disease then it creates a world where anything could be excusable. However, his claims atomic number 18 confound and do not consider enough sustenance points to extrapolate the concept better. Stanley Peele starts his agate line by disagreeing to the statement that says more or less the great unwashed in America believe that addiction is a disease. Yet, he fails to provide a reason for his disagreement. Hence, it is stiff to accept his conclusion due to insufficient reasons and unsatisfactory arguments. Stanley Peele?s starts his main argument appealing to authority. He states that Governor Dukakis puts addiction as ?a sickness? since addicts suffer from a physiologically well define phenomenon. However, it is uncertain that addiction is a health check condition since it has not been proven. Basically, Stanley Peel says that addiction is not a disease since thither is not proof to support that declaration. much(prenominal) argument comparable this is certainly an appeal to ignorance.
The author has to advert here that his start out to prove addiction is not a disease has been ill-advised too. He fails to say wherefore addiction should not be consi dered as a disease. contend other authors? ! point of views or statements to prove his claims are objurgate does not necessarily prove his argument to be true. Thus, Stanley Peele should have included, in his passage, how an addiction itself is unlike form a disease. He could have used examples to prove... If you lack to get a generous essay, order it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com
If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper
No comments:
Post a Comment